JotCast | MLBTR Live Chat With Jason Martinez: September 21, 2016

MLBTR Live Chat With Jason Martinez: September 21, 2016

View Full Chat Next Page

Jason Martinez

4:31

Thanks for joining me! As always, lots of interesting topics to discuss. I'll get to as many questions as possible.

John Coppaplayer

4:32

Ender Inciarte and Aaron Blair for Carlos Rodon. Who says no?

Jason Martinez

4:32

I love Inciarte but I'm not sure his value high enough to net Rodon after he was so bad in the 1st half.

Daniel

4:34

Kershaw for CY Young? And if not and your argument is IP, why is Britton a legitimate candidate and Kershaw isn't?

Jason Martinez

4:34

I'd still give it to Kershaw. He was so far ahead of everyone else when he went on the DL. It gave a few guys a chance to get caught up but I think he made it back just in time.

Daniel C

4:36

Is Vogelbach Seattles everyday first basemen next year?

Jason Martinez

4:36

That would be my guess. Nothing left to prove in AAA. They need to find out if he's the guy. D.J. Peterson could push him for the job if they stay in house.

Mike

4:37

What are the chances the Yankees go after Rich Hill this offseason?

Jason Martinez

4:37

I think Hill gets at least 2 years and $26-$30MM. Any team willing to go that high will be in the mix, including the Yankees. Most teams need starting pitching.

M.J.

4:39

Hey Jason. I enjoy the chats. Keep up the good work. Which of the 90's-early 00's trades was the worst for Cleveland and why? (1) Danny Graves, Damian Jackson, and Scott Winchester to Cincy for John Smiley and Jeff Branson (2) Sean Casey to Cincy for Dave Burba and Eddie Priest (3) Steve Karsay and Steve Reed to Atlanta for John Rocker and Troy Cameron (4) Richie Sexson to Milwaukee for Bob Wickman, Jason Bere, and Steve Woodard (5) Jeromy Burnitz to Milwaukee for Kevin Seitzer (6) Steve Kline and Herbert Perry to the Expos for Jeff Juden (7) Brian Giles to Pitt for Ricardo Rincon

Jason Martinez

4:39

No. 7. Giles was good for a long time after they traded him.

Ben F

4:41

Dodgers could use dozier? What would be a good return?

Jason Martinez

4:41

I'd guess 2 of the 4 ... Urias, De Leon, Bellinger, Verdugo.

JR white

4:43

Where does Blake Swihart finally breakout? If not in Boston, where?

Jason Martinez

4:43

Not with the Sox. His value is down if he's not going to be a catcher. I think he needs to re-establish his value in AAA next season and the Sox could shop him if he puts up big offensive numbers.

M.J.

4:47

What are your thoughts on the criticism Paul Hoynes of the Cleveland-Plain Dealer has faced from fans, media, and players for his piece a few days ago on the Tribe having no chance in the playoffs?

Jason Martinez

4:47

On the surface, it sounded like he was doing his job and players were pissed because he wrote a negative article. Not cool. However, I don't know what the track record is and if there is a reputation for Hoynsie always being negative. It was a strongly worded article. I stick with words like "likely" and "probably" often in my articles because baseball is so unpredictable. But I also think it's great when a writer will express a strong opinion.

Michael

4:48

Do the Cardinals retain Jaime Garcia then trade him?

Jason Martinez

4:48

Tough call. $12MM for one year of Garcia is reasonable. I think they'd explore it. Despite his late-season struggles, he's had a decent overall season and, surprisingly, has been able to stay healthy.

Loria

4:50

Should the marlins trade Fernandez ?

Jason Martinez

4:50

Every GM should explore every trade possibility. I just don't know if the Marlins will take a step back after they were able to stick around in the pennant race for the entire season. Not really a good message for that fan base, even if they got a huge return with a few elite prospects.

Ben F

4:51

I think kris Davis would look good in a red sox jesery. Cheep fill for Ortiz leaving.

Jason Martinez

4:51

Cheap only applies to his salary. He'd cost a lot in a trade after hitting 40 HRs.

TheGreatPablo

4:53

With the loss of Carrasco who has the advantage going into the playoffs Cleveland or Red Sox?

Jason Martinez

4:54

I might've picked the Red Sox, anyways, because they have a much more experienced and battle-tested roster. But not having Carrasco or Salazar hurts.

Kj adams

4:57

Yankees offseason plans?

Jason Martinez

4:57

Top of the rotation starter is the clear priority. Maybe one late-inning reliever.

Steve

4:58

Ahmed Rosario makes his debut in...?

Jason Martinez

4:58

With Reyes/Cabrera under contract for 2017, I think it would take an injury for him to debut before September. I'd guess early 2018 after a full season in AAA.

Cub Fan, Bud Man

5:01

Baez, Almora, Jimenez and soler for Fernandez...who says no

Jason Martinez

5:01

Not a bad haul for the Marlins. Crazy that the Cubs could trade that kind of talent and only lose one player (Baez) who has played an integral role in 2016. I actually don't think the Cubs would do it for only 2 yrs of Fernandez. Maybe if they could negotiate a long-term deal before the deal is finalized.

Rox Guy

5:03

Assuming no trades, what do the rockies do with Para and Tapia?

Jason Martinez

5:04

I think the depth gives them some options this offseason. Makes sense to trade at least one of their outfielders. I also don't think it's necessary. Parra is a good 4th OF and it wouldn't hurt to have Tapia in the minors for another season.

Michael

5:05

Should the Mets gone after a different bat than Bruce?

Jason Martinez

5:05

Easy to second guess it now, but Bruce was having a great season and seemingly formed a perfect 1-2 punch with Cespedes. Some guys don't do well with the change of scenery.

Lucas

5:06

How long do you think Brandon Crawford is going to be out.

Jason Martinez

5:06

I bet he'll do everything in his power to return in the next few days. Can't imagine he'll be very effective at the plate, though.

Stinger

5:09

Do you expect to see Asuaje, Renfroe, and Margot starting on opening day 2017?

Jason Martinez

5:09

I don't. Unless they trade Schimpf or Solarte, Asuaje doesn't really have a place to play. He could be a utility man and get a few starts per week. Renfroe and Margot have a better chance. Especially with Jankowski not finishing strong.

Chris

5:10

Do the Braves finish over .500 next year?

Connecting…

Your current subscriptions

None

E-mail Address	Chat Owner	Status	Remove

Enter your email address to be notified when Jason Martinez hosts a chat